Sci-fi author Holly Lisle resigns from the Science Fiction Writers of America over the *shocking* idea that the organisation might start winning funds to pay grants to writers. Because of course an additional funding stream for sci-fi writers is the Worst Imaginable Crime Ever.
“Giving” grants taken from tax dollars is nothing less than theft of taxpayer money. This action forces people who have no interest in the careers of writers receiving grants to support those writers’ work, no matter how distasteful, badly written, or objectionable they might find it.
It is institutionalized thuggery, and were I to remain a member, I would brand myself complicit with the thugs.
It’s always trivially easy to demonstrate the short sightedness of Libertarian “thinkers” of this kind. Ms Lisle is an author who wants to sell popular fiction to the masses. How on earth does she intend to do this without the tax funded state education system and the massive increase in literacy rates it facilitates? Unless of course she intends her work to be audio only.
PS – among the vast number of famous authors have received state grants is none other than…J K Rowling! Without the £5000 grant she received from Arts Council England to write Harry Potter, the British economy would have lost billions from its publishing, film, culture and tourism industries. Awww…Libertarians are fun but not so smart.
4 thoughts on “But who will read Holly Lisle’s books?”
There are various state funded grants for writers in New Zealand. And there is no question about the benefits for the richness of the country’s cultural depth, quite apart from direct financial spinoffs. The only problem comes when access is controlled by in-crowds, as has happened from time to time despite various checks and balances.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve encountered that problem myself, and in fact it strongly impacts my level of support for grants. Very important public institutions guard against cliques.
They do – and it’s important. These grants have tangible and intangible payback in so many ways, and not just for the author.
I live in Hawaii. Everything is controlled by in-crowds, which starts to wear on an out-crowder like myself. However, art with no support is often art that doesn’t get made, so there you are.