That Clomping Foot Again

So. What’s the problem with “worldbuilding” then?

You’ll probably have noted that M John Harrison won the Booker Prize. Mike, or “The M John” as I call him in my head, is a very important writer to me. A chat with The M John at WorldCon 2005 in Glasgow basically started me writing SF criticism. I’ve read most of his fiction and non-fiction, and still own Parietal Games, his collected criticism.

Mike became literary editor of New Worlds magazine in his early twenties, and alongside writers like JG Ballard and Michael Moorcock, strongly rejected the idea of SF as “genre fiction” and treated it instead as something more like a literary tradition.

So, Mike’s Booker win is a little more complicated than “literary mainstream finally recognises science fiction”.

As anyone who picks up Mike’s Booker winner The End of Everything will discover, or reads the Kefahuchi Tract trilogy, or Viriconium saga, whether Mike is writing space opera, or epic fantasy, or alien invasion, he’s never writing genre fiction.

If there is a Them and Us between Scifi and LitFic, Harrison was always more one of Them. Or at the very least a covert double agent.

Which might be why Mike Harrison has always remained an SF writer’s SF writer, and never been a bestseller of any kind.

In fact, until the Booker, what Harrison was most infamous for was a blog post published in 2007 that’s known as “The Great Clomping Foot of Nerdism”.

An attack on “worldbuilding”.

The post incited a very, very angry response at the time. Online “cancel culture” was just emerging, and Mike got badly dogpiled by online SF fandom. Mike even deleted the original post. But you can still find it on Google. The post resurfaces every few years, and the anger sparks up again.

Because Mike isn’t only attacking worldbuilding.

Sure, yes. Tolkienesque worldbuilding is basically a cargo cult. The nerd level substitute for not learning the much harder job of storytelling.

The poetic tools of metaphor, symbolism and myth are so woolly and unclear. It’s much more comforting to write a worldbook than struggle with the text itself.

And it’s that “comfort” which Harrison is really attacking.

In his 1971 New Worlds essay A Literature of Comfort, a young Harrison argues that SF is really the grown-up equivalent of Beatrix Potter. Aliens instead of talking rabbits, but still the same “world” to escape into.

Mike’s blog post enraged people because it expresses a contempt for science fiction, as immature escapism, the kind of thing scifi nerds heard from bad teachers and worse parents.

If the Clomping Foot does make you angry, it’s worth asking why someone who has dedicated their life to SF is struggling with their own contempt for SF. Because it is a struggle. Harrison is writing the post to himself. The clomping foot is his own.

Talking about all of this with Mike back in 2005 started me thinking critically about SF. Twenty years later I still agree with Mike’s critique of worldbuilding. But I expand it much further.

It’s not just scifi nerds who are lost in escapist fantasies. It’s all of us. Every human alive. The scifi nerd is honest enough to call our fictions what they are, while most of humanity is angrily bulldozing reality to make it fit our fantasy. You think scifi is escapist? Try a shopping mall.

But now I’m channelling JG Ballard 🤣

Published by Damien Walter

Writer and storyteller. Contributor to The Guardian, Independent, BBC, Wired, Buzzfeed and Aeon magazine. Special forces librarian (retired). Teaches the Rhetoric of Story to over 35,000 students worldwide.

One thought on “That Clomping Foot Again”

Comment